1991 (Inaugural year)
- Gary Steffensmeier--First Team
- Jamie Byrne--Third Team
- Cory Manning--Third Team
1992
- Gary Steffensmeier--First Team
1993
- Jamie Byrne--Honorable Mention
- Andrew Showalter--Honorable Mention
1995
- Justin Greenlee--First Team
Compiler:
Compiled by Jonathan Russell; edited by Susan A. Basye May 1997